COO

Ryan Mahoney

Ryan Mahoney

Director of Product, FirstWho

This role sits at a brutal intersection: close enough to the work to smell the burning wires, far enough to be accountable for the system. You need someone who can hear what engineering is not saying about technical debt while translating that into budget language the CFO actually accepts. The real test is not running a process improvement workshop; it is telling a founder their favorite vendor contract is a liability, then rebuilding that relationship without losing the tool entirely. Most candidates can do one side of this. The rare ones hold both tensions without collapsing into pure diplomat or pure enforcer. Look for evidence they killed a popular project because the math stopped working, not because someone senior asked them to.

Skip the setup

Use as-is, or remix to fit your team.

Start hiring now

Competency Questions

1 of 21

Organizational & Customer Experience

Talent systems administration, customer success operations, and knowledge management to optimize human capital and reduce organizational friction.

Customer Success Operations

Manages customer success platforms and health scoring systems; oversees support workflows and escalation processes.

Interview round: Cross-Functional Leadership Panel

Describe how you built visibility into customer health and success that actually helped the team prioritize and intervene. What did you create, and how did it land?

Positive indicators

  • Acknowledges false positives and negatives in health scoring
  • Describes specific interventions triggered by health signals
  • Shows empathy for CSM workflow and cognitive load
  • Mentions how they handled data gaps for new or small customers

Negative indicators

  • Proposes perfect predictive model without organizational readiness
  • Ignores CSM feedback on signal quality
  • Focuses on dashboard creation without usage
  • Shows no awareness of customer segmentation needs

Attitude Questions

1 of 19

Active Listening

The disciplined cognitive and behavioral practice of fully concentrating on, comprehending, and responding to spoken and unspoken communication in ways that validate the speaker's perspective, surface latent meaning, and create psychological safety for complete information sharing. For COOs, this involves suspending operational solutioning temporarily to ensure all stakeholder knowledge—especially inconvenient or politically sensitive intelligence—is fully extracted before integration into decision-making.

Interview round: Recruiter Screen: Culture & Role Fit

You're in a planning session where two department heads are talking past each other, both insisting the other doesn't get it. You've been asked to help. What's your first move?

Positive indicators

  • Proposes separate conversations before joint problem-solving
  • Mentions checking for unstated goals or fears driving positions
  • Describes neutral language to reflect back what they heard
  • Considers timing and setting for productive dialogue

Negative indicators

  • Immediately proposes compromise without deeper understanding
  • Sides with one party based on title or relationship
  • Jumps to process or framework without diagnosing the gap
  • Assumes bad faith or incompetence from one party

Progression Framework

This table shows how competencies evolve across experience levels. Each cell shows competency at that level.

Organizational & Customer Experience

4 competencies

CompetencyJuniorMidSeniorPrincipal
Customer Success Operations

Coordinates support ticket routing and basic customer data management; assists with CS metric tracking.

Manages customer success platforms and health scoring systems; oversees support workflows and escalation processes.

Designs customer success operations and retention strategies; implements CS technology stack and predictive health models.

Architects customer experience ecosystems; establishes enterprise-wide customer data platforms and success methodologies.

Knowledge Management

Maintains documentation repositories and assists with content organization; supports knowledge base updates and user queries.

Manages knowledge management systems and documentation standards; implements information architecture and content governance.

Designs organizational knowledge strategies; establishes enterprise search, content management workflows, and learning repositories.

Architects knowledge ecosystems and organizational learning infrastructure; pioneers AI-enhanced knowledge discovery and retention systems.

Security Compliance & Governance

Assists with compliance documentation and audit evidence collection; tracks security training completion and policy acknowledgments.

Manages compliance programs and security audits; coordinates risk assessments and implements security awareness training.

Leads security and compliance strategy; designs governance frameworks and manages regulatory relationships across jurisdictions.

Establishes enterprise risk governance architecture; shapes industry security standards and manages board-level cyber risk reporting.

Talent Systems & Workforce Operations

Coordinates HR administrative tasks and data entry; supports onboarding logistics and maintains employee records.

Manages HRIS configuration and recruiting operations; oversees onboarding programs and workforce analytics reporting.

Designs talent systems architecture and organizational development programs; leads workforce planning and HR technology strategy.

Architects global talent operating models; establishes people technology ecosystems and organizational design for scale.

Strategic & Financial Operations

4 competencies

CompetencyJuniorMidSeniorPrincipal
Financial Planning & Analysis

Supports budget tracking and variance analysis; maintains financial spreadsheets and assists with basic reporting templates and data entry.

Owns departmental budgeting cycles; develops financial forecasts and coordinates with accounting on month-end close processes and budget variance explanations.

Leads annual financial planning process; designs financial operating models and advises C-suite on capital allocation, burn rate optimization, and fundraising readiness.

Architects enterprise financial strategy; manages board-level financial reporting and investor relations while establishing fiscal governance policies for multi-entity structures.

Revenue Operations & Financial Systems

Supports billing operations and revenue data entry; assists with accounts receivable tracking and basic pricing list maintenance.

Manages revenue systems configuration; owns billing workflows, pricing implementation, and coordination between sales and finance on revenue recognition.

Leads RevOps strategy and systems architecture; designs pricing models, commissions structures, and scalable billing processes for growth stages.

Architects revenue infrastructure for global scale; establishes financial systems roadmap and leads M&A integration of revenue operations.

Strategic Procurement

Researches market options for strategic suppliers; assists in RFP processes and data collection for sourcing decisions.

Manages strategic sourcing projects; evaluates enterprise vendors and coordinates cross-functional selection committees for major purchases.

Leads strategic procurement initiatives for core infrastructure; negotiates enterprise agreements and establishes preferred vendor programs.

Sets organizational procurement philosophy; architects supply chain resilience strategies and manages C-level vendor partnerships.

Vendor & Contract Lifecycle Management

Assists in vendor research, contract filing, and performance tracking; maintains vendor databases and compliance documentation.

Negotiates standard vendor contracts; manages ongoing vendor relationships, conducts cost-benefit analyses, and resolves service delivery issues.

Owns vendor portfolio strategy and complex negotiations; builds vendor governance frameworks and manages strategic supplier partnerships.

Designs ecosystem partnership strategies; establishes enterprise-wide procurement policies, vendor risk frameworks, and category management methodologies.

Technical Infrastructure & Product Delivery

4 competencies

CompetencyJuniorMidSeniorPrincipal
AI Operations & Infrastructure

Supports AI tool evaluation and basic prompt engineering; monitors AI system usage and assists with data preparation.

Implements AI workflows for operational processes; manages AI vendor relationships and integration projects with existing systems.

Leads AI transformation roadmap for operations; establishes AI governance, prompt libraries, and automation frameworks.

Pioneers AI-native organizational design; shapes industry best practices for operational AI deployment and ethical AI governance.

Data Platform Engineering

Supports data pipeline maintenance and monitoring; assists with basic ETL tasks and data quality checks under supervision.

Develops and maintains data pipelines and warehouse models; manages data integration projects and ensures data quality standards.

Architects data platform strategy and infrastructure; designs data governance frameworks and scalable analytics architectures.

Establishes organizational data strategy and platform architecture; pioneers data mesh or similar paradigms and leads data ethics governance.

Engineering Reliability & DevOps

Monitors system alerts and assists with incident response coordination; maintains runbooks and documentation.

Manages on-call rotations and incident response processes; implements monitoring solutions and reliability improvements.

Leads site reliability engineering practices; designs incident management frameworks and infrastructure automation strategies.

Establishes organizational reliability standards; architects disaster recovery and business continuity systems at enterprise scale.

Product Delivery Orchestration

Coordinates meeting logistics and tracks project tasks; assists with status reporting and documentation of delivery processes.

Manages sprint planning and release coordination; facilitates cross-functional communication and removes blockers for delivery teams.

Leads delivery operations for product divisions; implements agile frameworks, capacity planning, and delivery metrics systems.

Architects organizational delivery systems; establishes portfolio management practices and scales engineering operations across multiple teams.